NDN Collective Hosts ICWA Conversation with Rebecca Nagle Ahead of Major Supreme Court Case that Threatens Tribal Sovereignty

Brandi Douglas · November 7, 2022

NDN Collective Hosts ICWA Conversation with Rebecca Nagle Ahead of Major Supreme Court Case that Threatens Tribal Sovereignty

Brackeen v. Haaland (2021) is a case whose ruling could shake the entire foundation of the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA), impacting Native American children, families, land and Tribal sovereignty as we know it.

This Wednesday, November 9th, the United States Supreme Court will hear Brackeen v. Haaland (2021), a case whose ruling could shake the entire foundation of the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA), impacting Native American children, families, land and Tribal sovereignty as we know it.

One person who has been following this case diligently is Rebecca Nagle, Cherokee journalist, host, producer, and writer of This Land Podcast. On Thursday, October 27th, NDN Collective’s Director of Tactical Media, Lorenzo Serna, sat down with Rebecca for an NDN LIVE discussion on what the Indian Child Welfare Act is, how it is under attack, who is organizing these efforts, and what this means for ICWA and the sovereign rights of Tribal Nations across the so-called United States. 

Lorenzo Serna, NDN Collective Director of Tactical Media, sits down with Rebecca Nagle, Cherokee journalist, host, producer, and writer of This Land Podcast, during the October 27th NDN Live discussion on ICWA and the Brackeen case.

Enacted in 1978, the Indian Child Welfare Act was established with a purpose “to protect the best interest of Indian Children and to promote the stability and security of Indian tribes and families.” ICWA would achieve this by establishing minimum Federal standards for the removal of Indian children that ensures they are placed in the homes of Native families. 

During the NDN Live discussion, Nagle describes ICWA as, “a set of guardrails. So when a native child is up for adoption or enters the foster care system, it’s a set of guardrails to try and keep that child first with their family, with their tribe and then also connected to native communities.”

In the Brackeen v. Haaland (2021) case, which originated as a custody dispute of a Native American child, these guardrails are being challenged, and the Federal standards which were established 44 years ago to protect “Indian” children, are at stake.

Rebecca Nagle, Cherokee journalist, host, producer, and writer of This Land Podcast.

For Native communities across North America, these efforts are reflective of the removal of Native children during the Indian Boarding School Era, which began in the late 19th and early 20th century wherein Native children were forcibly removed from their families and communities as a part of assimilative efforts to strip them of their culture and communal ties.

Brackeen is challenging the constitutionality of the Indian Child Welfare Act, as it places preference for the placement of Indian children to the tribes themselves.  Gibson Dunn, the legal team backing this effort on the side of the Brackeens, are attempting to challenge not only ICWA, but other areas where the sovereign powers granted to Native Tribes and Nations are exercised. 

A chart identifying the anti-Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) organizations and key players. Credit: Crooked Media.

In prior years, Gibson Dunn has supported major oil and gas companies like that of the Dakota Access Pipeline (DAPL), among other companies who have contributed to worldwide environmental crises. Gibson Dunn also played a part in representation of companies in another area where sovereignty has been continuously challenged – Indian gaming. Their legal tactics in the gaming arena are reflective of the same argument in the Brackeen case.

“So Gibson Dunn has a really big casino and gaming portfolio,” said Nagle in the livestream conversation “They represent two of the three largest casino companies in the world. And this past January, Gibson Dunn filed a federal complaint saying that actually the legal structure of Indian gaming that allows tribes to operate casinos on Tribal lands where non-native casino developers can’t have casinos is unconstitutional. And the legal arguments that Gibson Dunn is using in that case are the exact same legal arguments that they’re using in Brackeen.” 

A timeline documenting anti-ICWA efforts beginning in the 2000’s up until present day. Credit: Crooked Media.

But what about the Indian Child Welfare Act is Gibson Dunn deeming discriminatory and unconstitutional? Depriving non-native families of the right to adopt Native children?

“They’re saying, the way that ICWA defines who is an Indian child and who is an Indian family is treating people differently based on race,” said Nagle. “And according to the 14th amendment of the Equal Protection Clause, we can’t treat people differently based on race in the United States. That’s discrimination and therefore it was unconstitutional.”

On season 2 of the This Land podcast, Rebecca Nagle does a deep dive into not only the Brackeen case, but the history of the Indian Child Welfare Act, starting with the boarding school era, speaking to survivors and unveiling the decades worth of effort by non-native families, legal teams and courts to unravel the sovereign protections afforded to Tribes and Nations in protecting their children.

On November 9th, the Supreme Court will hear oral arguments in Brackeen v. Haaland (2021). Photo by Claire Anderson on Unsplash.

This Wednesday, November 9th, the Supreme Court of the United States will hear oral arguments for the Brackeen v. Haaland (2021) case. NDN Collective will be streaming LIVE on the ground in Washington, D.C. to hear from ICWA advocates, attorneys and more on this groundbreaking case.

Tune into our Facebook | Twitter | Youtube channels at 10am MT/11am CT/12pm ET to be a part of this groundbreaking moment.

Listen to Season 2 of the This Land podcast:

Protect ICWA Campaign graphic developed by National Indian Child Welfare Association, National Congress of American Indians, Association on American Indian Affairs and the Native American Rights Fund.


Resources for Survivors, provided by Crooked Media

Take action now to defend the Indian Child Welfare Act!

Learn more about the history of Brackeen v. Haaland + the history of ICWA on the following websites:

Brandi Douglas
by   Brandi Douglas

Brandi Douglas (she/her/they/them), Senior Communications Associate, is a Puyallup Tribal member as well as Black and Mexican. In their role, they provide support to the Communications and Narratives Team as well as all aspects of content production, targeted outreach and internal communications. Brandi is an avid wordsmith, having uplifted various narratives that speak to the experience of being an Indigenous entrepreneur, multi-racial and queer. 

They have served as a Civil Court Clerk for the Puyallup Tribe, Paralegal for the Puyallup Tribal Prosecutor and Unemployment Benefits Navigator/Paralegal for the Native American division of Northwest Justice Project.

Brandi holds a Bachelor’s degree in Global Studies as well as a Paralegal Certification from the University of Washington. They hold a Master’s degree in Indigenous Peoples Law from the University of Oklahoma. 

In 2019, Brandi was instrumental in helping to establish the first ever Puyallup Tribal Pride event and is currently working towards assembling a 2SLGBT+ Committee at the Puyallup Tribe while continuing to aid in planning Puyallup’s yearly Pride celebration.

They are currently a Native Women Lead Board member and they were a 2020 South Sound Magazine 40 Under 40 recipient.

March 2023 Edition

Stay Informed. Take Action.

Subscribe to the NDN allies newsletter

Sign up to get our newsletter. Delivered once per month.

We care about the protection of your data and would never sell your email or share it with anyone without your permission.

NDN Collective Responds to Forest Services Commitment to Study Mining Impacts in the Black Hills Posted 11 months ago
“This is a victory for Tribal Sovereignty. The fight to protect ALL of the water of the sacred Black Hills continues and we remain vigilant and committed to this duty. We stand in solidarity with communities that have been defending Ȟešapa for generations, when our treaties are honored it protects the water for everyone.”
NDN Collective Slams Biden Greenlighting Willow Oil Project Posted 12 months ago
“The Biden administration’s decision to greenlight the Willow project is a climate disaster in the making. Today’s decision completely contradicts not only the administration’s climate goals, but also its commitment to consider Traditional Ecological Knowledge in federal policy making."
Willow Project Threatens Traditional Caribou Hunting: Naqsragmiut Tribal President Writes Letter to the DOI Requesting Consultation Posted 12 months ago
"Residents of our community described concerns about potential impacts to our primary diet, Caribou, to global warming, and to our way of life. BLM has not come back to our community this time and we feel our people and their concerns have been overlooked."
Consultation Process Inadequate: New Letter from Nuiqsut Community Leaders to Department of Interior Posted 12 months ago
It seems that despite its nod to traditional ecological knowledge, BLM does not consider relevant the extensive knowledge and expertise we have gained over millennia, living in a way that is so deeply connected to our environment.
Paying Respects to the American Indian Movement, 50 Years since the Occupation of Wounded Knee

Brandy Calabaza

Posted 12 months ago
NDN Collective joins hundreds at the American Indian Movement 4 Directions March commemorating the 1973 Occupation of Wounded Knee, and members of the team share reflections on the power and purpose of the day.
NDN Collective Joins Tribes, Organizers, and Activists Across Turtle Island in Mobilization to #StopCopCity

Sherrie Anne Hart , Angelica (Angie) Solloa

Posted 1 year ago
"Building Cop City on stolen Indigenous Lands, to inflict violence in a Black neighborhood, on a piece of land that is essential for air quality and much needed biodiversity to combat climate change is racist, unjust and the opposite direction that we need to be heading in."
NDN Collective Announces the 2023 Radical Imagination Grant Open Application Period Posted 1 year ago
Ten Indigenous artists, artist collectives or small nonprofits of all artistic traditions, mediums and genres will be awarded $100,000 grants over two years.
Police Assault Indigenous Youth with Disabilities at Central High School Posted 1 year ago
"We must prioritize resources and solutions that promote restorative justice, mental health services, and other interventions that address the root causes of conflict, rather than relying on punitive measures that perpetuate the cycle of violence and harm."
“Medicine in a world of violence”: Shining Light on Community-led Efforts to fight the MMIR Epidemic

Janene Yazzie

Posted 1 year ago
Challenging the commercialization of February 14, NDN Collective’s Southwest Regional Director Janene Yazzie calls attention to the MMIR (Missing and Murdered Indigenous Relatives) Day of Awareness, National Day of Action, and grassroots efforts to fight the MMIR epidemic. Yazzie also shares future MMIR programming from NDN Collective coming soon.
10 Books by Black and & Afro-Indigenous Authors on Black History, Liberation and Futurism Posted 1 year ago
A list curated by Afro-Indigenous Staff at NDN Collective in honor of Black History Month.

United like never before, we rise together—arm in arm—to equip all Indigenous Peoples with the tools needed to become architects of our future. Through a holistic approach to infrastructure, funding, advocacy, movement building, and philanthropy we are fostering a world of justice and equity for all people and the planet.